Which listings deserve your time
If someone has offered to put your practice on dozens of directories, or told you AI assistants now pick dentists from directories, this post is for you. We ran patient-style San Diego searches through ChatGPT and Perplexity on two days and counted the sources in every answer. This post, part of our Grow Your Practice Online series, sets those counts beside what Google says and what one vendor claims, and ends with a keep, update or skip table.
What Google says listings do
Google's page on local ranking says "Local results are mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity." Under its Prominence heading, it says this factor is "based on info like how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have." The page does not mention directories. Our reading: a directory page that links to your website is one of those websites, but Google does not say a listing on any particular site helps you rank.
Google does say it gathers facts about your office from elsewhere. Its page on how it sources business information lists "Publicly-available information, such as crawled web content" and "Licensed data from third parties," alongside what users and owners contribute. The ranking page adds: "If your business info isn't accurate, your Business Profile might not show up for relevant searches in your area." So the strongest case for listings is accuracy, not volume. For the rest of the map picture, see our post on why a practice is missing from the Google Maps top three.
How we tested
We ran five prompts through ChatGPT search and Perplexity, logged out, in a fresh desktop browser, on the evenings of October 23 and 24, 2026, Pacific time. We planned three days; this is two. The connection came from a Los Angeles datacenter IP address, not a San Diego patient's phone, so San Diego reached the engines only through the words in each prompt.
A run counts only if an answer came back. Perplexity often turned logged-out visitors away: on the first day, four of its five prompts hit a sign-in wall or a Cloudflare security check on the first try and on three retries each; on the second day, two of five hit the security check and were not retried. ChatGPT's first pass on the second day returned empty pages for four prompts, so we re-ran those once with a longer wait and counted the re-runs. That leaves 14 valid runs, 10 from ChatGPT and 4 from Perplexity, and every count below leaves the invalid runs out.
A source counts when the answer linked to it or printed its name as a source label. Directories mostly appeared as small text labels such as yelp.com or Birdeye, not as links, and both engines hide extra sources behind a "+1" or "10 sources" button we did not open, so every figure is a floor. With 14 runs, read the counts as a pattern, not a rate. We do not name or rank any practice from the answers. The prompts, word for word:
- best dentist in North Park San Diego
- emergency dentist open Saturday in Chula Vista
- family dentist in Escondido with good reviews
- dentist in Vista CA that takes Delta Dental
- Invisalign dentist in La Jolla
What the answers used
Every valid answer named at least one local practice, and most linked straight to practice websites. Directories were the minority:
| Source | ChatGPT, Oct 23 | ChatGPT, Oct 24 | Perplexity, Oct 23 | Perplexity, Oct 24 | All valid runs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A practice's own website (link) | 4 of 5 | 3 of 5 | 1 of 1 | 3 of 3 | 11 of 14 |
| Any named directory or review site | 3 of 5 | 2 of 5 | 0 of 1 | 1 of 3 | 6 of 14 |
| Delta Dental's provider directory (link) | 1 of 5 | 1 of 5 | 0 of 1 | 0 of 3 | 2 of 14 |
| Yelp (text label) | 2 of 5 | 1 of 5 | 0 of 1 | 0 of 3 | 3 of 14 |
| Birdeye (text label) | 1 of 5 | 1 of 5 | 0 of 1 | 0 of 3 | 2 of 14 |
| Yably (text label) | 0 of 5 | 1 of 5 | 0 of 1 | 0 of 3 | 1 of 14 |
| Zocdoc (link) | 0 of 5 | 0 of 5 | 0 of 1 | 1 of 3 | 1 of 14 |
| A google.com link | 2 of 5 | 1 of 5 | 0 of 1 | 0 of 3 | 3 of 14 |
| Healthgrades, Vitals, WebMD, RateMDs, ADA Find-a-Dentist, 1-800-DENTIST, Facebook, Bing or Apple Maps | 0 of 5 | 0 of 5 | 0 of 1 | 0 of 3 | 0 of 14 |
| Any dental association, news or publisher site | 0 of 5 | 0 of 5 | 0 of 1 | 0 of 3 | 0 of 14 |
Where directories showed up, and where they did not
The directories clustered on two kinds of question.
Insurance. For the Delta Dental prompt, ChatGPT leaned on the insurer's own directory both times and said so: the first closed its list with "Source: Delta Dental's Vista dentist directory," and the second said its picks were "listed in Delta Dental's own provider directory." Perplexity's one valid answer to that prompt linked Zocdoc instead. Our reading: when a patient asks by insurance plan, the plan's directory is a likely source, so it is a listing to get right.
Reviews. For the Escondido prompt, which asks for good reviews, both ChatGPT answers printed review-site labels beside the practices, with lines such as "reviews reported by Birdeye," plus Yelp and, on the second day, Yably.
Everything else. On the North Park and Invisalign prompts, no valid run named a directory or review site; apart from one unnamed "top picks" label, the answers linked practice websites or google.com. The emergency prompt showed a Yelp label once in three valid runs, and one emergency answer listed a dental referral service beside the offices. Some of the practices named changed between the two days; the overall pattern held: practice websites first, directories on the insurance and reviews prompts.
Asking about one business by name. In an earlier run on the same setup, on October 23, we asked both engines three questions about our own firm, an agency rather than a dental office. Five of the six answers named our profile on Clutch, a directory of agencies, and Perplexity noted that "Clutch has no posted client reviews." Our reading: when someone asks whether a business is any good, the answers look for third-party profiles, and an empty one gets noticed. That is six answers about one agency: a pointer, not a finding about patients.
What a vendor's index claims
One directory list worth checking comes from 5W, a PR firm whose page says it combines "public relations, digital marketing, Generative Engine Optimization (GEO)" and which sells a dental audit of AI answers. Its 2026 Dental AI Visibility Report says that when patients ask AI tools about dentists, "the answer comes from a tight cartel of nine directory and review properties": Google Business Profile, Healthgrades, Zocdoc, Yelp, Vitals, WebMD, ADA Find-a-Dentist, 1-800-DENTIST and RateMDs. For finder queries such as "best dentist near me," it says "Individual practice websites appear below all of these." The report describes its audit as spanning "three query types" and "eight procedure categories," but describes its audit as spanning "three query types" and "eight procedure categories," but gives no number of queries, no run dates and no searcher location, and the page is dated both June 15 and May 2026. These are 5W's claims, not Google's and not ours.
Our runs did not match them. Of the nine directory sites, only Google, Yelp and Zocdoc appeared, and a practice's own website appeared in 11 of 14 valid runs. Our sample is small and our prompts, engines and location differ from 5W's, so neither result settles the question. It does mean a list of directories you must be on is a claim to check.
For context, BrightLocal, which sells listing and review tools, surveyed 1,002 US adults for its Local Consumer Review Survey 2026. It reports that respondents used six review sites on average, that 45% of the adults BrightLocal surveyed now use AI tools for local recommendations, up from 6%, and that Healthgrades was among the sites whose use grew. Our reading: patients look in several places, which argues for accuracy where they look rather than presence on every list.
Bing Places and Apple Business
Neither Bing nor Apple Maps appeared by name in our runs, which tells you little: the answers often showed hours and phone numbers without naming a source. Both keep their own listing of your office; our post on Bing Places and Apple Business for dentists covers claiming and verifying each one.
Keep, update or skip: our advice
Counts are valid runs out of 14; the advice is ours.
| Listing | In our runs | Our advice |
|---|---|---|
| Google Business Profile | google.com link in 3 | Keep. It is the listing Google's ranking page is about. Verify and complete it first. |
| Your insurance plans' find-a-dentist directories | Delta Dental's, in both ChatGPT answers to the insurance prompt | Update. Check every plan you are in network with, for each location and dentist: name, address, phone, hours, plans taken. |
| Yelp | Label in 3 | Keep. Claim the page, correct the details, read the reviews. |
| Bing Places and Apple Business | Not named | Keep. Claim both and match them to Google. |
| Zocdoc | Link in 1 | Your call. If you list there, keep plans and hours current; our runs are no reason to start. |
| Healthgrades | 0 | Update if a profile exists; BrightLocal says its use grew. |
| Birdeye and Yably review pages | Labels in 2 and 1 | Skip as a project. They surfaced as sources for review counts; check once what they show. |
| Vitals, RateMDs, WebMD, ADA Find-a-Dentist, 1-800-DENTIST | 0 | Correct a wrong profile if you find one. Do not pay to be listed because a vendor's list names the site. |
| Your dental society's member directory | Not measured | Keep if you are a member: a real local link, the kind Google's prominence wording describes. |
| Unknown "top picks" or paid "best dentist" lists | 1 unnamed label | Skip. |
One name, address, phone and hours everywhere
The answers repeated listing details: addresses, phone numbers, Saturday hours, star ratings and accepted insurance. One ChatGPT answer said "Ratings and review counts are from available listings and may change." In two answers, a practice's star rating in the written list did not match the rating on the same answer's map card. For three practices, the phone number changed between our two days or between the two engines, and one address and phone number appeared under the practice's name on the first day and a dentist's own name on the second. A changed number may be a tracking line or an old one; either way, the patient dials whatever the answer shows.
Google's guidelines say "Your name should reflect your business's real-world name, as used consistently on your storefront, website, stationery, and as known to customers." Our advice: make your website the reference copy, match your Google profile to it as our Business Profile guide for dentists describes, then work down the table above:
- Put the practice name, full address with suite, main phone and hours on your website exactly as you want them shown.
- Match your Google Business Profile to it, then Bing and Apple.
- Search each insurance plan's directory for the practice and each dentist, and ask the plan to fix anything wrong.
- Claim or correct Yelp, and any Healthgrades or Zocdoc profile you already have.
- Ask ChatGPT and Perplexity about your practice by name and city, more than once, and note the sources. Fix a wrong detail at its source, not in the chat.
- Repeat after a move, a phone change or a new dentist, and once a quarter otherwise.
Where this fits
Our guide to ranking for "dentist near me" shows how listings fit with your profile, reviews and website.
Want us to check your listings?
Request a free audit and we will send a personalized video review of your website and local search presence. If you are at the San Diego Dental Convention on November 20-21, 2026, come by Booth 9 and we can look at your listings with you.

